Product Reviews

The 11 Best Puppy Collars For Your Furry Little One

iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Finding the best puppy collars is more than just a fashion statement; it’s an essential part of responsible pet ownership. From basic flat collars to specialized training types, the market is awash with options. The ideal collar can make a significant difference in your puppy’s comfort, safety, and even ease of training.

But with so many choices, materials, and features, how do you narrow down the right one for your furry friend? This comprehensive guide aims to answer that question, complete with expert reviews and insights into the critical factors like size, material, and type of collar best suited for puppies.

We’ll delve deep into the specifics you need to consider, answering the most frequently asked questions such as what size collar your puppy needs, when it’s appropriate to start putting a collar on them, and how to introduce them to this new accessory. From safety precautions like what to include on your puppy’s ID tag to advice on cleaning and replacing collars, this article will serve as your one-stop resource. Whether you’re a first-time dog parent or a seasoned pup owner looking for a refresher, this guide will arm you with the knowledge to select the best collar for your puppy’s unique needs.

puppy dog collar

Buyer’s Guide: What to Consider When Choosing a Puppy Collar

Choosing a collar for your puppy is an important decision that involves several considerations, including safety, comfort, function, and even style. Here are some factors to consider when picking a collar:

Size and Adjustability

  1. Fit: The collar should fit snugly without being too tight or too loose. A general rule is that you should be able to slip two fingers between the collar and your puppy’s neck.
  2. Growth: Puppies grow quickly, so look for adjustable collars that can accommodate your puppy as they grow.
  3. Width: A wider collar will distribute pressure more evenly across the neck, which is better for larger or stronger breeds.


  1. Durability: Materials like nylon and leather are generally durable and comfortable for a puppy to wear.
  2. Comfort: Look for soft materials that won’t chafe or irritate your puppy’s skin.
  3. Weather Resistance: If you live in a wet climate or your puppy will be swimming, consider a water-resistant material.

Safety Features

  1. Quick Release: A quick-release clasp can be helpful in emergencies.
  2. Reflectivity: If you will be walking your dog in low-light conditions, a collar with reflective material is a good idea for added visibility.
  3. ID Tags: Make sure there’s a sturdy D-ring where you can attach an ID tag that includes your contact information.
  4. Breakaway Collar: For cats and sometimes small dogs, these collars are designed to release when snagged, reducing the risk of choking. This is less common for dogs but can be a consideration.


  1. Training: If you’re using the collar for training, you may require additional features like rings for lead attachment or even electronic components for advanced training. Note that training collars like choke, prong, or shock collars are considered negative reinforcement methods and can cause physical harm and damage your bond with your dog.
  2. Activity Level: If your dog will be very active or engaged in specific types of work or sports, you may need specialized collars that are designed for those activities.

Style and Personal Preferences

  1. Color and Design: Choose a design and color that you like, and that looks good on your puppy. However, don’t sacrifice functionality and safety for style.
  2. Matching Leash: Some people like to buy a leash that matches or coordinates with the collar.

Remember that the best collar for your puppy is the one that meets its specific needs in the most comprehensive way. Always consult your vet or a qualified dog trainer if you have questions or concerns.

The 11 Best Puppy Collars

#1 – Patriotic Pup 🇺🇲 American Flag Dog Collar

Patriotic Pup American Flag Dog Collar

  • High-quality nylon material
  • Vibrant American flag design
  • Quick-release buckle
  • Sturdy D-ring for leash attachment
  • Every purchase feeds 2 shelter dogs

For those who want to showcase their national pride or celebrate patriotic holidays with their pup, the Patriotic Pup American Flag Dog Collar is a fitting choice. Made from high-quality nylon, this collar is both durable and lightweight, making it comfortable for your puppy. The American flag pattern is vivid and eye-catching, perfect for events like the Fourth of July or Memorial Day. While the collar is more of a fashion statement, it doesn’t compromise on essential features; it includes a sturdy D-ring for leash attachment and a quick-release buckle for easy on and off.


  • Stylish and patriotic design
  • Durable and comfortable material
  • Easy to put on and remove
  • Suitable for special occasions or everyday wear


  • Pattern may fade with time or harsh conditions
  • No reflective features for added safety
  • May be better suited for large breed and older puppies

#2 – Joytale Reflective Dog Collar

BRONZEDOG Rolled Leather Dog Collar with QR ID Tag

  • Reflective material for increased visibility
  • Durable nylon construction
  • Adjustable for growing puppies
  • Sturdy D-ring for leash attachment
  • Separate loop for ID tags

The Joytale Reflective Dog Collar is a versatile and safety-focused choice that is particularly well-suited for puppies. One of its standout features is its reflective material, which increases your puppy’s visibility during low-light conditions—a boon for those late evening or early morning walks. Made from durable nylon, the collar is designed to withstand the playful antics of a lively pup, while still being gentle on their delicate skin. The adjustable fit allows room for growth, which is essential for fast-growing puppies. The collar also features a sturdy D-ring for leash attachment and a separate loop for ID tags, ensuring your puppy is both safe and identifiable. Overall, this collar provides an excellent blend of durability, comfort, and safety features that make it a solid choice for any puppy owner.


  • Enhanced safety due to reflective material
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Adjustable, allowing for growth
  • Easy to clean


  • May not be suitable for very small or toy breeds due to width
  • Some users might prefer more color options
  • Reflective material may wear off over time with heavy use

#3 – BRONZEDOG Rolled Leather Dog Collar with QR ID Tag

BRONZEDOG Rolled Leather Dog Collar with QR ID Tag

  • Rolled leather to prevent fur matting
  • QR ID Tag for quick identification
  • High-quality construction
  • Available in various sizes

The BRONZEDOG Rolled Leather Dog Collar brings sophistication and technology together with its quality leather and QR ID Tag feature. Rolled leather is especially good for puppies with longer fur as it helps to prevent matting and tangling. The QR ID Tag is an innovative feature that allows anyone with a smartphone to quickly access your contact information, making it easier to reunite with your puppy if they get lost. The collar is well-constructed, offering durability that stands up to the wear and tear puppies are known for. While leather may require more upkeep than nylon, it often becomes more comfortable over time. Overall, this collar offers a stylish yet functional choice for those who want an extra layer of security for their puppy.


  • Excellent for puppies with longer fur
  • Innovative QR ID Tag adds an extra layer of security
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Stylish design


  • Leather may require more maintenance
  • Higher price point
  • Limited color options

#4 – Blueberry Pet Essentials Personalized Dog Collar

Blueberry Pet Essentials Personalized Dog Collar

  • Customizable embroidery
  • High-density polyester webbing
  • Eco-friendly plastic buckle
  • Chrome-coated D-ring

For dog parents looking for customization, the Blueberry Pet Essentials Personalized Dog Collar offers a unique touch. The collar can be personalized with your puppy’s name and your phone number, which is embroidered directly onto the fabric for added safety. Made from high-density polyester webbing, this collar is both durable and soft, making it suitable for puppies. The buckle is made from eco-friendly plastic, and the D-ring is chrome-coated for durability. However, unlike other options, this collar lacks a reflective feature for increased visibility. Still, the customization aspect sets it apart, making it a great gift or special keepsake for your new furry family member.


  • Personalization adds a unique touch
  • Durable and comfortable material
  • Eco-friendly components
  • Good variety of colors and styles


  • No reflective feature for added safety
  • Embroidery might wear off over time
  • Non-adjustable once customized

#5 – GAMUDA Puppy Collars

GAMUDA Puppy Collars

  • Made from durable nylon
  • Variety pack for multiple colors
  • Adjustable design
  • Quick-release buckle

The GAMUDA Puppy Collars pack offers value and variety, ideal for multi-pet households or puppy parents looking for an affordable but reliable option. Made from robust nylon, these collars are designed to be durable yet lightweight, offering your young puppy comfort without compromising on quality. They come in an assortment of colors, allowing you to easily identify multiple puppies or simply change up the look from day to day. Although they lack advanced features like reflectivity or ID tags, they do have a straightforward, adjustable design and a secure quick-release buckle. While these collars may not offer all the bells and whistles of some other brands, their simplicity and affordability make them a good choice for basic everyday use.


  • Affordable and good value
  • Suitable for multi-pet households
  • Lightweight and comfortable
  • Easy to adjust


  • Lacks advanced features like reflectivity or ID tags
  • May not be as durable as higher-end options

#6 – Mile High Life Dog Collars

Mile High Life Dog Collars

  • Nylon with neoprene padding
  • Dual D-ring system
  • Reflective strip for visibility
  • Multiple sizes and colors available

The Mile High Life Dog Collars bring together functionality and aesthetics in a durable package that’s great for puppies. With a blend of nylon and neoprene padding, these collars are designed for both durability and comfort. One standout feature is the inclusion of a dual D-ring system that offers added security while walking your pup. The collar also comes with a reflective strip, making your puppy more visible in low-light situations. While it’s great for everyday use, it might be a bit much for very small puppies due to its somewhat thicker design. Overall, the Mile High Life Collar provides a solid combination of essential features and extras, making it a highly versatile choice for puppy parents with bigger babies.


  • Comfortable and durable
  • Enhanced safety with dual D-rings
  • Reflective strip for added visibility
  • Versatile for larger puppy sizes


  • May be too thick for very small breeds
  • Neoprene might retain odors
  • Could be pricier than basic collars

#7 – House of FurBaby Rhinestone Dog Collar | Light Pink Sparkle | Personalized Dog Collar

House of FurBaby Rhinestone Dog Collar | Light Pink Sparkle | Personalized Dog Collar

  • Rhinestone embellishments
  • Personalized name and contact plate
  • Multiple sizes
  • Light pink sparkle design

For those seeking a bit of glamour for their four-legged friend, the House of FurBaby Rhinestone Dog Collar in Light Pink Sparkle offers a unique, stylish option. The collar features a row of securely fastened rhinestones that add a dash of elegance. The personalization option allows you to have your pup’s name and your contact number etched onto a plate, combining style with practicality. While it is eye-catching, the collar may not be suitable for highly active or rough-playing puppies, as the rhinestones could potentially come loose. It’s a fabulous choice for special occasions but might not be the best for everyday wear and tear. All in all, this collar is perfect for those who want their puppy to make a stylish statement.


  • Stylish and unique
  • Personalization adds a practical touch
  • Good for special occasions
  • Durable etching on the name plate


  • Not ideal for highly active puppies
  • Rhinestones could potentially come loose
  • May not be as durable for everyday use

#8 – Weewooday 4 Pcs Pink Dog Collars

Weewooday 4 Pcs Pink Dog Collars

  • Faux leather with cute designs
  • Pack of four different styles
  • Adjustable fit
  • Pink color scheme

The Weewooday 4 Pcs Pink Dog Collar set is perfect for those with a puppy princess who likes to look good. Made of faux leather, these collars come in a pack of four with blingy, floral, and bowtie designs. While they may not be the most practical for day-to-day activities like running and playing, they make for a fun, occasional accessory. However, be cautious when letting your puppy interact with other animals, as the spikes and studs could be a hazard. These collars are adjustable, but the material may not be as durable or comfortable as other options like nylon or real leather. Overall, this set offers a distinctive look but may be better suited for occasional use rather than everyday wear.


  • Unique and edgy look
  • Comes in a set for variety
  • Adjustable for growing puppies
  • Good for occasional and daily use


  • Material may not be as durable as other options

#9 – Blaoicni 3 PCS Puppy Collar and Leash Set

Blaoicni 3 PCS Puppy Collar and Leash Set

  • Soft, durable polyester
  • Matching leash included
  • Adjustable fit
  • Quick-release buckle

The Blaoicni 3 PCS Puppy Collar and Leash Set offers great value for new puppy parents looking for a matching set. Made of soft, durable polyester, these collars are both comfortable for the puppy and easy to maintain. The set comes with a matching leash, making it convenient for those who prefer a uniform look. The collars are adjustable and feature a quick-release buckle for added safety. One downside is that the set lacks any sort of reflective material for enhanced visibility. Nevertheless, if you’re seeking an affordable, matching collar and leash set, the Blaoicni option is a sensible choice.


  • Great value with matching leash
  • Soft and comfortable material
  • Adjustable to fit growing puppies
  • Quick and easy to put on and remove


  • Lacks reflective material
  • May not be as durable as higher-end options
  • Limited in advanced features

#10 – Rhea Rose Cow Print Dog Collar

Rhea Rose Cow Print Dog Collar

  • High-quality fabric
  • Unique cow print design
  • Standard D-ring for leash attachment
  • Easy to clean

The Rhea Rose Cow Print Dog Collar is perfect for puppy parents who appreciate quirky and unique designs. Made from high-quality fabric, this collar is both durable and comfortable. The cow print pattern is fun and stylish, making your puppy stand out in a crowd. While it lacks advanced features like reflectivity or a quick-release buckle, it does offer a standard D-ring for leash attachment. The material is easy to clean, although the pattern may fade over time with regular washing. Overall, this collar offers a unique and fashionable option for those less concerned with advanced features.


  • Unique and stylish design
  • Durable and comfortable fabric
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Suitable for everyday use


  • Lacks advanced safety features like reflectivity
  • Pattern may fade with regular washing
  • No quick-release buckle

#11 – SimpleThings Airtag Dog Collar

SimpleThings Airtag Dog Collar

  • Designed to hold an Apple Airtag
  • Durable nylon material
  • Tracking capabilities via smartphone
  • Various sizes available

In today’s tech-savvy world, the SimpleThings Airtag Dog Collar is a step ahead in providing enhanced security and peace of mind. Specifically designed to hold an Apple Airtag, this collar allows you to easily track your puppy’s location through your smartphone. Made from durable nylon, the collar is both robust and comfortable. While the Airtag feature is its major selling point, it’s worth noting that the Airtag itself must be purchased separately. Additionally, the collar lacks reflective material for enhanced visibility. However, for those concerned about their puppy wandering off, the SimpleThings Airtag Collar offers a modern solution to an age-old problem.


  • Offers peace of mind with tracking capabilities
  • Durable and comfortable
  • Suits tech-savvy puppy parents
  • Good for growing puppies due to its adjustable nature


  • Airtag must be purchased separately
  • Lacks reflective features for added safety
  • May be pricier due to its specialized design

best puppy collar

FAQs About Collar for Puppies

When it comes to puppies and collars, people often have a range of questions, especially if they are first-time dog owners. Here are some of the most frequently asked questions:

About Choosing a Collar

What size collar does my puppy need?

Determining the right collar size for your puppy is crucial for both comfort and safety. As a general rule, you should be able to slip two fingers between the collar and your puppy’s neck to ensure it’s not too tight. Measure your puppy’s neck circumference using a flexible measuring tape and then add an extra 1-2 inches for smaller breeds or 2-3 inches for larger breeds. Most collars are adjustable, and it’s wise to choose one that allows for growth, especially since puppies can grow quickly. Always double-check the manufacturer’s sizing guidelines, as sizing can vary between brands.

What type of collar is best for a puppy?

The best type of collar for a puppy generally depends on its breed, size, and your specific needs (such as training). For most puppies, a standard adjustable collar made of nylon or leather works well. These are durable, easy to clean, and come in various sizes and designs. Martingale collars can be suitable for breeds with narrower heads like Greyhounds, as they prevent the dog from slipping out of the collar. Training collars like choke, prong, or electronic collars should be avoided. Always prioritize safety features like quick-release clasps and ensure that the collar has a D-ring to attach an ID tag.

When can I start putting a collar on my puppy?

Introducing a collar to your puppy can generally begin as early as 8 weeks old, but this varies depending on the breed and individual dog’s comfort level. Start by putting the collar on for short periods while supervised, gradually increasing the time as the puppy gets accustomed to the sensation. It’s essential to monitor your puppy closely during this adjustment period to ensure that they’re not uncomfortable or showing signs of distress. Use positive reinforcement to make the experience as pleasant as possible. Consult your vet to confirm the appropriate age and type of collar for your specific breed and size of puppy.

Is it safe to leave a collar on my puppy all the time?

The safety of leaving a collar on your puppy all the time depends on various factors, including the type of collar and the environment in which your puppy spends most of its time. In a controlled environment like a securely fenced yard or inside the home, it is generally safe to leave a well-fitted collar on. However, if your puppy will be unsupervised in areas where the collar could get caught on something (like a crate, branches, or fencing), it’s safer to remove it to reduce the risk of choking or injury. Some parents opt for breakaway collars that release if the collar gets snagged, offering an extra layer of safety. Always ensure the collar is well-fitted and regularly check for signs of wear and tear.

About Training and Behavior

How do I get my puppy used to wearing a collar?

Acclimating your puppy to a collar is a gradual process that should be approached with patience and positive reinforcement. Begin by allowing your puppy to sniff and investigate the collar so that they can get used to its smell and appearance. Next, put the collar on for short periods while you are directly supervising them. During this time, engage in play or give treats to create positive associations with wearing the collar. Gradually extend the amount of time the collar is worn each day, always watching for signs of discomfort or distress. If your puppy seems irritated, check the fit and condition of the collar to ensure it’s neither too tight nor causing chafing. Within a short period, most puppies adjust well to wearing a collar, but always consult your vet if you notice any issues like skin irritation or excessive discomfort.

Can a collar help with training my puppy?

A collar can indeed be a useful tool in training your puppy, particularly when it comes to leash training and basic obedience commands like “come,” “sit,” and “stay.” Standard flat collars are usually sufficient for basic training, but some trainers and parents prefer specialized training collars that might produce a sound or have a handle for more targeted behavior modification.

Regardless of the type of collar you use, consistency and positive reinforcement are key in any successful training program. Always consult with a certified dog trainer or your vet to determine the best training approach for your puppy.

About Safety and Health

What should I put on my puppy’s ID tag?

An ID tag is an essential accessory for your puppy’s collar, acting as the first line of defense in case they get lost. Typically, the tag should include the puppy’s name and at least one reliable contact number where you can be reached. Some parents also choose to include additional information, such as a secondary contact number, their home address, or even an email address. Medical information, such as if your dog is microchipped or needs medication, has specific allergies, etc., can also be useful. However, space is usually limited on tags, so include the most critical information first. Some pet parents opt for QR code tags that can be scanned to reveal more detailed information stored online.

Can a collar hurt my puppy’s neck or trachea?

A poorly fitted or inappropriate collar can potentially harm a puppy’s neck or trachea. Collars that are too tight can cause chafing, skin irritation, and restricted breathing. On the other hand, collars that are too loose can easily slip off, making it unsafe for the puppy when outdoors. Certain types of collars, such as choke chains or prong collars, can exert excessive pressure on the trachea if not used correctly, potentially leading to injury, and therefore should not be used. Small breeds with delicate necks are particularly vulnerable to tracheal collapse, so a harness might be a safer option for these dogs.

How often should I check the collar’s fit?

Puppies grow rapidly, especially in the first few months, so it’s crucial to check the fit of the collar regularly. As a rule of thumb, you should be able to comfortably slip two fingers between the collar and your puppy’s neck. Some experts recommend checking the collar’s fit every week for very young puppies and at least once a month as they grow older. Always adjust the collar as needed to ensure it remains snug but not tight. Failing to adjust the collar can lead to discomfort, skin irritation, or even more serious issues like choking if the collar becomes too tight as the puppy grows.

About Material and Maintenance

What material is best for a puppy collar?

The best material for a puppy collar often depends on your puppy’s specific needs, including their size, activity level, and any skin sensitivities they may have. Nylon is a popular choice due to its durability, affordability, and wide range of colors and styles. Leather is another solid option, as it’s durable and tends to become more comfortable over time. However, leather may require more maintenance to keep it in good condition. For puppies with sensitive skin, hypoallergenic materials or padded collars may be beneficial. For active or water-loving dogs, you might consider synthetic materials that are quick-drying and resist odors. Always consult your vet for advice tailored to your specific breed and individual puppy.

How do I clean my puppy’s collar?

Cleaning your puppy’s collar depends on the material from which it’s made. Nylon collars can often be machine-washed or soaked in warm, soapy water, rinsed, and then air-dried. Leather collars should not be submerged in water; instead, they can be cleaned with special leather cleaners or a damp cloth, followed by a leather conditioner to maintain their flexibility and sheen. Always check the manufacturer’s instructions for specific care guidelines. Keeping the collar clean is important not just for aesthetic reasons but also to prevent the buildup of bacteria that could irritate your puppy’s skin.

How often should I replace my puppy’s collar?

The frequency with which you should replace your puppy’s collar depends on several factors including how quickly your puppy is growing, the collar’s material, and its overall condition. Puppies grow quickly, so you may find yourself needing to size up several times in the first year alone. Aside from growth, look for signs of wear and tear like frayed fabric, a damaged clasp, or a rusted D-ring, as these can compromise the collar’s safety. Some materials like leather can last for years if well-maintained, while nylon or cloth may need to be replaced more frequently. Always inspect the collar regularly to ensure it’s in good condition and fits well.

Remember, while there are general answers to these questions, the best advice will always take into account the specific breed, size, and needs of your puppy. Consulting a vet or a certified dog trainer can provide tailored advice that is best for your pet.

collar for a puppy

Final Thoughts About Puppy Collars

In conclusion, choosing the right collar for your puppy is a decision that impacts their comfort, safety, and your peace of mind. By considering factors like size, material, and your training goals, you can make an informed choice that suits both you and your new four-legged family member. This comprehensive guide aims to make the process easier, offering you all the information you need to select the best puppy collars that will grow with your pet through the many happy years to come.

iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button